In a landscape where smartphone prices continue to climb, Apple's latest entry-level offering, the iPhone 17E, priced at $599, is positioning itself as an affordable gateway to the iOS ecosystem. Launched recently alongside the similarly priced MacBook Neo, the iPhone 17E boasts premium features like 256GB base storage and MagSafe wireless charging, making it appealing for budget-conscious consumers seeking flagship-like experiences without the full cost. However, according to a recent analysis by CNET, the device's fiercest competition may not come from inexpensive Android alternatives but from Apple's own older models, which offer comparable or superior features at similar price points.
The iPhone 17E arrives at a time when Apple has retired its iPhone SE line, leaving fewer low-cost iOS options on the market. CNET contributor, referencing a review by colleague Abrar Al-Heeti, highlighted the phone's solid build and user-friendly design. 'In her iPhone 17E review, my colleague Abrar Al-Heeti praised the phone's feel, higher base storage of 256GB and the inclusion of MagSafe,' the analysis noted, underscoring its value as a new entry-level device.
Despite these positives, the piece argues that shoppers in the sub-$600 range have compelling alternatives within Apple's lineup. For instance, the iPhone 15 is available new for as low as $530 at retailers like Best Buy, particularly when activated with carriers such as AT&T or Verizon. This model edges out the 17E in camera capabilities, featuring not only a 48-megapixel wide-angle lens but also a 12-megapixel ultrawide camera that enables 0.5x magnification for broader shots—features absent on the single-camera 17E.
Apple's Certified Refurbished program further bolsters these options, offering devices that have been inspected, repaired if needed, and backed by a warranty. According to CNET, a 128GB refurbished iPhone 15 is priced at $529, while the 256GB version goes for $619—just $20 more than the 17E. 'The more versatile dual-rear camera system is an easy reason to choose the iPhone 15, not to mention video features like Cinematic mode and Action mode, which aren't available on the 17E,' the analysis stated, emphasizing the trade-offs for new buyers.
Moving up the ladder, the iPhone 16, which starts at $630 new with carrier activation at Best Buy, also supports advanced functionalities like Apple Intelligence, Apple's suite of AI-driven features. A refurbished 128GB iPhone 16 is available for $619 through Apple, though it lacks the 256GB storage of the 17E. Opting for 256GB on the iPhone 16 refurbished model pushes the price to $699, a $100 premium over the 17E, but buyers gain the ultrawide camera and a programmable Action button.
For those willing to venture into the used market, even more powerful options emerge. CNET pointed to the iPhone 15 Pro, a 2023 flagship, as a standout alternative. 'Feature-wise, the iPhone 15 Pro blows the iPhone 17E out of the water in every way but processing power,' the report observed. This model includes a triple-camera setup with a 3x telephoto lens and the A17 Pro chip, which also enables Apple Intelligence.
Prices for used iPhone 15 Pros vary by condition and seller, but deals are plentiful on platforms like Amazon, Gazelle, and BackMarket. As of the latest reporting, a 512GB iPhone 15 Pro in 'Renewed' condition—meaning at least 80% battery capacity—sells for between $557 and $600 on Amazon, depending on color. The 'Renewed Premium' version, with 90% battery health, costs around $620 and may show minor cosmetic wear but remains fully functional.
Battery life remains a critical consideration for used purchases. The CNET analysis drew from personal experience with a refurbished iPhone 13 Mini, purchased to test longevity four years after its release. 'When I tried out a used iPhone 13 Mini, I was constantly bothered by its reduced battery capacity,' it recounted, noting the device's 83% maximum capacity led to frustrating daily use. Apple recommends battery replacement below 80% capacity, costing $99 for iPhone 15 and 16 models at official stores, though third-party options exist at the risk of voiding warranties.
Many used sellers provide limited warranties and return windows, offering some buyer protection. In the case of the iPhone 13 Mini tested, a 90-day return period allowed the owner to identify battery issues within 15 days. For the iPhone 15 Pro, such policies can mitigate risks, potentially making it a worthwhile investment despite the unknowns of pre-owned devices.
The launch of the iPhone 17E parallels Apple's strategy with the MacBook Neo, its $599 entry-level laptop unveiled concurrently. Both aim to refresh value segments by supplanting discounted older models rather than directly challenging budget competitors from other brands. Yet, while the MacBook Neo is seen as a strong upgrade over prior MacBook Airs on sale, the iPhone 17E faces stiffer internal rivalry due to the wealth of recent iPhones still in circulation.
Apple Intelligence, a key selling point for newer models like the iPhone 16 and 15 Pro, represents one area where the 17E shines with its latest processor. However, opting for the iPhone 15 means forgoing this feature for now, though CNET noted that much of it, including an enhanced Siri, remains in development. 'You do lose Apple Intelligence access by choosing the iPhone 15, but at this time, you aren't missing out on much,' the analysis clarified.
For consumers upgrading from devices older than the iPhone 15, the 17E's modern processor and ample storage could justify the spend. It supports MagSafe for accessories and offers sufficient space for media without immediate need for cloud reliance. Still, the report urges shoppers to weigh features against cost, especially as iOS updates ensure longevity across generations.
A comparison chart in the CNET piece lays out specs side-by-side: the iPhone 17E with its single 48MP camera and A18 chip versus the iPhone 16's dual cameras and Action button, the iPhone 15's similar setup without AI, and the iPhone 15 Pro's advanced telephoto and ProMotion display. Prices range from $529 refurbished to $699, highlighting how older flagships can deliver more for marginally more money.
As Apple continues to streamline its portfolio post-SE retirement, the iPhone 17E fills a void but underscores a broader trend: the value of established models in a premium-priced market. Experts suggest that with careful shopping—whether new, refurbished, or used—consumers can access iOS perks without stretching budgets. Looking ahead, upcoming software updates and potential discounts on flagships could further tilt the scales, prompting buyers to monitor promotions at retailers like Best Buy and Apple's own stores.
In the end, the choice hinges on priorities: the assurance of a brand-new device with the iPhone 17E, or the enhanced capabilities of predecessors like the iPhone 15 or 15 Pro. As one CNET observer put it, 'The iPhone 17E is a good option for a new phone... But it's important to know your options if you're shopping within this price range for iOS devices.' With sub-$600 iPhones scarce, informed decisions will define the next upgrade cycle for millions of users.